petitminion Can happend but it's can be considered has a mb db error and it's not a common case.
Do you have zero experience on how MusicBrainz works whatsoever? I have been editing for about 8 years and I am repeatedly telling you why this is not true because this is not how MusicBrainz works. You do not want to listen.
petitminion And about differents master I think most of the people don't care and don't even have the audio system to ear the differences.
Right, but you don't get to decide whether that's true.
And Funkwhale should not coincide with your use case perfectly, you are only one user. The way you want Funkwhale to operate breaks the use cases of many more people than the ones it "fixes", which it doesn't even fix, it just makes it more convenient for people who have tagged their music incorrectly which is ironically the opposite of what you vouch for.
petitminion In your previous comments you where saying a track should not be associated to a release mbid if it's a standalone recording..
A track should be linked against every relevant combination of MBIDs it has stored, and matched to none of the ones it doesn't have.
This means that a file from one release should never be used on another release, and files which do not have a release MBID should be presented separately.
petitminion I don't see how it's confusing but in any case if there is no album tag we will use the album we have in db. If the album is not in db we will pick one randomly from mb db.
But this is you guessing what the community in large wants. Which I can already tell is wrong because MusicBrainz does not work like this.
petitminion But I don't see how this is related to multiple audio file per recording
A MusicBrainz recording can be associated with multiple releases, but a recording can be associated to multiple very different versions of the audio which only work played together if the rest of the files were retrieved exclusively from that release.
I keep telling you MusicBrainz recordings do not fulfill the purpose you want to use them for and you refuse to listen.
EDIT: Alright, I'm about done here. I honestly can't keep spending energy I do not have on this kind of behavior. It's not right for me to continue.